A week or so ago, I was contacted by an old acquaintance who
wanted my opinion on whether his 70-year-old aunt should consult with a
fee-based financial professional or one who is paid on commission? Before I
could respond, he proceeded to inform me that, based on his research, they were
leaning toward the fee-based advisor.
Quick side note: Generally
speaking, fee-based advisors are paid a percentage of the money that you invest
– commonly called money-under-management – for as long as you keep your money with
that advisor. Commissioned folks, on the other hand, receive a one-time commission
check up front.
As with most things, each of these
options has pluses and minuses. But the fact of the matter – and the point I’m
trying to drive home here – is that there is no litmus test in this regard, absolutely
NONE! Obviously, how an advisor gets paid is important. But let’s leave the
emotion out of it for just a moment to consider this: Is the way an advisor gets
paid the best barometer of his or her effectiveness/ability to deliver the products/services
you need?
Personally, I think other critical aspects
should guide whom you hire. How about personal integrity, real-life expertise
in successfully delivering the kind of results you’re seeking, and regulatory
oversight issues? As I said earlier, the mode of compensation is important, but
we must be careful not to let it crowd out other equally – if not more – important
issues for consideration.
As my acquaintance admitted, he
reached out to me because he was getting a bit confused sifting through the
myriad viewpoints around which route his aunt should take.
My first question (after asking him
how he’s been) was: What, specifically, is
your aunt looking to accomplish? As it turned out, all the “drama” was
completely unnecessary because his aunt was interested in buying a Single
Premium Immediate Annuity (SPIA). Whoever winds up selling it to her will be
paid a commission, because that’s the ONLY way a SPIA pays the professional involved. When
the place you’re travelling to doesn’t have a train station, why would you
spend hours trying to decide whether to drive or take the train?
Every situation is different, and therefore
demands a different evaluation process, but the takeaway here is that there’s
no cut-and-dried litmus test on one advisor being better than the next solely based
on how he/she is paid – not to mention that, as in this case, such a comparison
may be moot.
Now in the interest of full disclosure, in case you were wondering which model I fall under: Depending on the particular service or product for
which you engage me, I could be fee-based, commission-based, or charge a flat-fee.
_______________________
Do you have questions or concerns about your finances and retirement investments? Call us today at 877.656.9111 or visit us on the Web to schedule your no-strings-attached consultation!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Chime in with your comments or questions: